You might be a model citizen, or perhaps someone who occasionally runs afoul of the law. You may even be a hardened, professional criminal. Regardless of your relationship with the rules, nobody wants to wind up in the back of a police cruiser, handcuffed and facing a night behind bars. Only the most self-loving criminals relish having their police photo taken. But whether you’re a wannabe lawbreaker or a novice, nobody desires their station snapshot plastered across the internet for ridicule while dressed in some outlandish getup. So, it was unfortunate for these 14 individuals arrested on Halloween. Get ready for some of the silliest arrest photos ever captured by law enforcement… (Pictures: TNI PRESS LTD)
If Justin Long portrayed The Joker
We commence with the first of several Jokers. And, as we’ll observe, not the most egregious. Not even close. There’s an irony more delicious than any Halloween treat, witnessing someone arrested while dressed as the most infamous comic book villain of all time. This wrongdoer isn’t fully committed to the ideals of Arthur Fleck’s other side, though. Just look at how glum he appears. A mere peek at this young man’s mugshot begs the question… Why the long face? (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Be Prepared… to bunk in a cell
This Florida resident, aged 24, was picked up for resisting arrest on All Hallows’ Eve. His transgression? Well, that doesn’t seem to be a sanctioned Boy Scout Association neckerchief slide. But an unauthorized neckerchief clasp isn’t – or so we believe – against Florida law. Whatever this zombie scout did, it was enough to land him in the local detention center for a short spell. Dressed as a boy scout on Halloween is rather odd, don’t you think? On that note, it’s likely a tad less dubious than dressing up as a scout leader on Halloween. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Flushed with embarrassment
Here we find Dusten Jacob Williams, age 20, from the state of Oregon. He was apprehended by officers on Halloween night for strolling down the streets displaying a BB gun modified to resemble a genuine firearm. That is troubling conduct, regardless of your perspective. But it is, undeniably, even more disconcerting when you’re attired as some sort of semi-demonic Darth Maul figure. It goes without saying that Dusten was left embarrassed following his encounter with Oregon law enforcement. Although we would like to emphasize that no one is implying that those black eyes were caused by the arresting officers. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Perspiration-man
This individual, in spite of having been taken into custody by the authorities, appears rather content with his situation, wouldn’t you agree? Perhaps there’s a sense of self-satisfaction derived from dressing up as The Caped Crusader. We simply hope that the bloke is the owner of this Batman outfit and that it wasn’t a rental. Those underarm sweat marks aren’t going to disappear in the laundry, are they? Not from 100% polyester. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Hi-yo, Silver! Make a getaway!
Way back in 2007, Mr. Travis Stone was taken into custody by Las Vegas PD for operating a vehicle under the influence after he lost command of his motor vehicle and slammed into a barrier. Yes, you heard correctly, Silver Surfer had abandoned his magical metallic surfboard, opting for a (most likely also metal) Mercedes. The upside? Thankfully, no one was harmed, as the barrier was just that, a barrier, and not someone in a barrier costume for Halloween. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
No laughing matter
Our second Joker, this disruptive New Yorker was taken into custody by the NYPD for making a scene at an Applebee’s. It’s not something you can imagine the actual Joker undertaking, is it? His criminal activities tend to have a slightly higher price tag than that. To be fair, Applebee’s isn’t generally considered a high-end dining establishment, but the chain doesn’t warrant a supervillain disrupting the peace and flinging chicken tenders about, does it? Where’s Batman when you need him? (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Fright night of the ill-mannered undead
Kevin Fearn here was busted by police, giving the medical profession a bad name. The 47 year-old was arrested at a Halloween bash dressed as a zombie physician on October 30, 2011 after bothering a fellow reveller. Now, it’s widely known that the living dead are not the most well-behaved, wouldn’t you say? But we’ve never come across a zombie sexually harassing anyone. Although it’s also important to point out that consuming people’s brains is far from ideal party etiquette, either. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
At long last – someone suitably attired
And the accolade for Most Ironically Appropriate Halloween Mugshot goes to… this bloke! It’s almost as if he was aware, hours before his capture, that he was potentially facing a conviction in the near future. After breaking the law on Halloween, this cosplay convict’s costume soon took on an eerie level of prescience. Good news for the officer responsible for doling out jail uniforms that night, though. Their newest occupant was already dressed for the occasion. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Not receiving any ‘Style Icon’ rewards
Introducing our third and last Joker… Now, judging by the standard of the make-up here, we’re suspecting that drunk-driver Dennis Lalime has never perused a Batman comic book. Or watched any of the numerous TV programs or feature films. He was on his way back from a Halloween event when he totalled his vehicle in Pittsfield, Maine. He had consumed alcohol, which is rather evident from his pathetic attempt to resemble The Joker. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Scarface says howdy to his miniature (cop) counterparts
If giving your parole officer the slip is on the cards, it may be best to give the costume contest a miss. A 32 year-old man from Michigan attempted to elude the authorities, but his Halloween attire made him simpler to spot than a pumpkin in summer. He quickly faced charges for absconding from parole, and – we’re guessing – devising a very uninspired Halloween outfit. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Prominent eyebrows really are trending again
The city of Lakeland in Florida is home to 22-year-old Ariana Motta. Her offense? Operating a vehicle while her driver’s license was suspended. That’s a relatively trivial violation, naturally. A reasonably insignificant misdemeanor. However, what’s not understated is her make-up. It’s actually quite impressive. If Florida state regulations mandated a license for applying make-up, Ariana could easily procure one. Whether it would be suspended or not is another matter entirely. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
The Dark Carnival gets even darker
Allow us to introduce Andrew Davis. Back in 2011, in Bartlesville, Oklahoma, he was caught by law enforcement looking like this. Unlike several of the less serious transgressions featured here, he was apprehended for something fairly severe. It is alleged that he struck an individual with his vehicle, dragging him 100 feet, before absconding from the scene. To make matters worse, he did so whilst wearing Juggalo face paint. As a dedicated follower of the Insane Clown Posse, stating that his conduct that evening was insane would be an understatement. ‘Andy the Clown’, as he preferred to be known, was charged with felony assault and battery with a dangerous weapon and leaving the scene of a motor vehicle accident involving injury. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Swapping the circus tent for the jailhouse
Right then. Clowns are unsettling. That’s beyond debate. What warrants further examination is the reasoning behind why Marlboro, Vermont resident Sean Barber chose to break into a dwelling and then fall asleep in one of the bedrooms. While dressed from head to toe in a full clown costume and make-up. The explanation for this puzzling act may be revealed by an additional offense he was arrested for: possession of cocaine. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
Udderly ridiculous!
For our concluding selection, we’ve held back the absolute pinnacle – and the most peculiar – for the end. This is Michelle Allen. She is a resident of Middletown, Ohio and was arrested for – brace yourselves – urinating on a neighbor’s front porch and pursuing some children down the street while outfitted as a cow. So far, so bizarre. The question we’d like to pose here is why Ms. Allen is still adorned in her bovine attire for her police photograph. We’d theorize that it could be the result of a prank by the police. But observe that smile. Michelle is happy in her cattle costume. And why not, eh? Let’s face it – it’s an exquisite ensemble. In reality, you could say… it’s totally brilliant. You could say, but please refrain from doing so. (Picture: TNI PRESS LTD)
BackStartNextNext Gallery
More Trending
As the NHS shares ‘benefits’ of first-cousin marriage — why is it still so controversial?
WeirdOctober 2, 2025By Jessica Lindsay
Politician hauled out of live TV debate after being mistaken for vegan streaker
I've got the world's longest name – it contains 2,253 unique words
$20 image of Jesus is leaking myrrh and performing miracles, believers claim
Breaking News
Never miss the biggest stories with breaking news alerts in your inbox.
EmailI agree to receive newsletters from MetroSign Up
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Your information will be used in line with our Privacy Policy
