The shapes of pupils vary extensively throughout the animal kingdom, ranging from the W-shaped pupils of cuttlefish to the bar-like pupils of goats. But what is the reason behind the diverse shapes of animal pupils?
The cuttlefish exhibits a W-shaped pupil.(Image credit: Katherine OBrien via Getty Images)Subscribe to our newsletter
It’s simple to consider pupils as mere openings that expand in dim light and contract in bright light. However, observing the animal kingdom reveals a diversity of pupil shapes: vertical slits in felines and serpents, horizontal rectangles in ungulates like goats and horses, and W-shaped crescents in cephalopods such as cuttlefish, for instance. The specific shape of an animal’s pupil can offer significant insights into its visual perception and its necessities for survival.
In an optimal optical configuration, the pupil’s shape should not be of great consequence. “In an ideal world, as optics is typically taught, the pupil is somewhat inconsequential because all light should converge at a single precise point anyway,” stated Jenny Read, a visual neuroscientist at Newcastle University in the U.K.
Yet, biological eyes are not perfect — incoming light through the pupil causes diffraction and defocus, which are resolved differently by various pupil shapes. “It actually transpires to be quite intricate,” Read commented.
(Image credit: Marilyn Perkins / Future)
Sign up for our weekly Life’s Little Mysteries newsletter to get the latest mysteries before they appear online.
A crucial element is the depth of field, as explained by Marty Banks, a professor emeritus of optometry at the University of California, Berkeley, to Live Science. His 2015 research published in the journal Science Advances was the inaugural study to systematically elucidate why the orientation of an animal’s pupil is vital for survival.
Depth of field is most readily comprehended using a camera lens, where the camera’s aperture functions analogously to a pupil. A restricted aperture yields an image where objects are in focus both at close and distant ranges from the camera. A broad aperture brings one object into sharp focus while rendering the foreground and background elements blurred. However, when a pupil deviates from a perfect circle, it can produce greater variability in focus, a phenomenon that certain animals’ eyes exploit.
Ambush predators, including felines and snakes, possess forward-facing eyes that gauge distance by comparing the subtle discrepancies between their binocular vision — a mechanism known as stereopsis. Due to the eyes’ lateral placement, these differences are most pronounced along vertical edges, necessitating sharpness in these areas.
“How does one ensure they are sharp? By constricting the pupil and enhancing the depth of field,” Banks explained. “But this is only needed for vertical contours. Thus, it is highly effective to narrow the pupil horizontally while keeping it wide vertically, as for other contours where stereopsis is not advantageous, such as horizontal contours, blur can then be utilized to estimate distance.”
This is the reason behind the slit-like pupils of ambush predators: Constricting the pupil horizontally aids stereopsis, while widening it vertically assists in estimating distance through blur.
Nevertheless, this strategy is most effective for predators situated close to the ground. Larger predators, such as lions and tigers, typically have circular pupils as they observe the ground from a steeper angle, which diminishes the benefit of blur for distance estimation.
Lions possess round pupils, contrasting with smaller predators like domestic cats and snakes that hunt close to the ground. (Image credit: Sebastien GABORIT via Getty Images)
Prey animals have distinct survival imperatives, and the configurations of their pupils reflect these differences.
“For prey animals, the focus is more on the field of view rather than image clarity,” Banks asserted. “They need the capacity for panoramic vision along the ground, as the majority of predators that might approach them will do so from ground level.”
Conversely, the eyes of prey animals such as goats, sheep, and horses are typically situated on the sides of their heads, and their pupils are shaped like a horizontal bar — elongated horizontally and short vertically. This expansive shape permits greater light intake from the horizontal plane in front and behind them, facilitating environmental scanning, while the narrow vertical aperture sharpens horizontal contours — essentially the inverse of what predators’ eyes achieve.
Prey species, such as goats, feature pupils shaped like horizontal rectangles. (Image credit: Stefania Pelfini la Waziya via Getty Images)
However, there is a challenge: A prey animal that lowers its head to graze would orient its horizontal pupils sideways, compromising its capacity to scan the horizon. Yet, these creatures have developed a remarkable adaptation, as Banks discovered: As the animal’s head changes position, its eyes rotate within their sockets to compensate.
“They have cultivated the ability to move their eyes in opposing directions on both sides of the head to maintain the pupil parallel to the ground,” Banks stated.
Other species exhibit even more peculiar pupil shapes, particularly in marine environments. Cuttlefish, for example, possess W-shaped pupils. Definitive explanations for this phenomenon are still elusive among scientists.
“Some researchers propose that this configuration renders them less conspicuous to other organisms,” Banks commented. “I am uncertain that a W shape would inherently be more difficult to detect than a circular one.”
Alternative hypotheses suggest that these pupil configurations might aid in diminishing light from above, thereby minimizing scattering and enhancing contrast. An early theory posited that the shape could contribute to color perception — cuttlefish possess only a single photopigment, which logically implies they should perceive only in monochrome, despite their vibrant coloration and exceptional camouflage abilities.
Banks’ research specifically addressed terrestrial animals, and he concedes that numerous aquatic pupil morphologies remain without clear explanations. Read speculates that the extent of the unknown may be even greater. “It prompts contemplation about what other visual capabilities might exist within animal eyes that we are currently unaware of,” she remarked.
Animal quiz: Test yourself on these fun animal trivia questionsTOPICS